Humans still make better surgeons than robots, study shows

Humans still make better surgeons than robots, carrying out operations in a shorter time yet making no more mistakes, a new study suggests.

Robotic surgery has increased substantially in the NHS since the first machines were installed a decade ago, and is commonly used for prostate, bladder and kidney removal as well as for cutting out tumours.

It was hoped that robots would be more accurate, dexterous and quicker than humans, but a new study has shown that they do not improve outcomes for patients, and operations take longer.

Researchers at Stanford University School of Medicine in the US reviewed nearly 25,000 operations across 416 American hospitals between 2006 and 2012.

They found that just 28 per cent of kidney removal patients who had keyhole surgery performed by a human surgeon were under the knife for more than four hours, compared to 46 per cent of those who were operated on robotically. Robotic surgery was also around £2,000 more expensive per patients.

Dr Benjamin Chung, associate professor of urology at Stanford , said: “We found that, although there was no statistical difference in outcome or length of hospital stay, the robotic-assisted surgeries cost more and had a higher probability of prolonged operative time.”

There are now around 60 ‘da Vinci’ machines in British hospitals offering assistive robotic surgery. Costing around £1 million each, the robots offer enhanced 3d vision and specialised instruments such as tiny cameras and ultra-small tools.

The researchers say that robots are undoubtedly helpful in tricky operations, which require a high degree of delicate maneuvering, or extensive internal stitching.

But for less technically challenging surgery, such as the removal of a whole kidney, the new study shows that humans are likely to be better.


Image Credit: The Royal Marsden


About Peter Coffaro 820 Articles
A growth-driven and strategic executive, Peter Coffaro commands more than 20 years of progressive management success within the orthopedic industry. Recognized by as one of the top medical sales influencers in the industry; he has 10 years of combined sales management experience and has held positions as a Director, General Manager and Distributor. Peter has worked for some of the top orthopedic companies in the world - Zimmer, DePuy and Stryker. He is also the founder of OrthoFeed: a popular blog that covers orthopedic news and emerging medical technologies. Peter is a three-time Hall of Fame award winner at Johnson and Johnson and has an extensive background in organizational development, business development, sales management, digital marketing and professional education. Peter holds a B.S. degree in Biology from Northern Illinois University.

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.